Skip to main content

The Minimalist’s Guide to Car Insurance: What You Can Actually Skip

 


Having good car insurance should mean having meaningful financial protection. It shouldn’t mean paying for bells and whistles you don’t need. Trim the fat from your policy by focusing on needs and critically reviewing the extras you don’t.

Know Required Coverage

Before you start cutting optional coverage from your car insurance policy, know what you should keep. There’s no sense in decreasing your financial protection from accidents you just to save money on your premium.

Go through your policy and highlight required coverage. Understand what you need and what you can optionally add. You can always adjust your coverage later as you determine your needs.

Know Your Car’s Value

Just because your insurance policy offers optional features doesn’t mean you should keep them as your car ages. You may be paying more for your policy than you ever recover in claims.

Know how much your car is worth versus how much you pay for insurance each year. As your car gets older, you may find optional coverage doesn’t give you much bang for your buck.

Decide If Comprehensive Is Right for You

Comprehensive coverage can protect you from theft, vandalism, natural disasters, and many noncollision-related incidents. For some drivers, there comes a time when keeping comprehensive coverage just doesn’t make sense.

       Compare how much your car is worth to what you pay for comprehensive coverage each year.

       Think about the likelihood of theft or harsh weather in your area.

       Consider if you could comfortably replace your vehicle.

       Review your insurance policy before making changes.

If comprehensive coverage no longer provides value, it might be time to let it go.

Think Twice About Collision Coverage

Collision coverage can help pay to repair your car if you are involved in an accident. Even if you are not at fault, your insurance company can require you to pay a deductible before they pay for repairs. If your car is older, you may think about dropping collision to save on your premium.

Before you drop coverage, take a minute to really understand what you could pay if you get into an accident. Don’t drop collision just to save money if it means you can’t comfortably cover repair bills or replacement costs.

Avoid Duplicate Coverage

Look for areas where your car insurance overlaps. You may already have coverage through your vehicle warranty or from a roadside assistance program attached to your credit card. Don’t pay twice for the same benefits.

Here’s a quick comparison of common sources of duplicate coverage to help you evaluate your car insurance policy:

Source of Coverage

Typical Features

Cost

Overlap Examples

Car Insurance

Roadside Assistance, Rental Car

$10-$30/month

Overlaps with credit card or auto club benefits

Credit Card

Roadside Assistance, Travel Protections

Varies (free/annual fee)

Similar to insurance add-ons

Vehicle Warranty

Repairs, Roadside Assistance

Included with purchase

Roadside overlaps with insurance

Auto Club

Roadside Assistance, Travel Discounts

$50-$150/year

Duplicates roadside insurance options

Use these comparisons to check your protections and ensure you aren’t paying double for identical benefits.

Go through your protections and see what you already have. If your insurance is offering duplicate coverage you don’t need, cut it from your policy.

Review Rental Coverage

If your car is in the shop due to a covered accident, you pay for a rental car through your insurance. Does your budget allow for you to pay for a rental car if your car is being repaired? You may decide you don’t need this coverage.

       Do you have another vehicle in your household you could use while your car is in the shop?

       Are you able to consistently use public transportation?

       How much does it cost to rent a vehicle where you live?

       How much would you save if you dropped this coverage versus how much you’d likely receive in benefits?

Don’t simply accept rental coverage because your insurance offers it. Take a look at your situation and make a decision that makes sense for you.

Compare Roadside Assistance

When your vehicle breaks down, do you have roadside assistance? Some insurance companies offer this as an add-on, but you may already be covered by an automobile club, your manufacturer, or through a roadside assistance program you bought.

Compare what each company offers and make sure you aren’t paying for the same benefit twice.

Increase Your Deductible

Your deductible is the amount of money you pay before your insurance pays on a claim. You can usually lower your premium by increasing your deductible. Before you do this, make sure you have enough in savings to cover repairs or total loss.

Just because your premium goes down doesn’t mean you’re saving money if you can’t come up with your deductible after an accident.

Skip Insurance Add-ons You’ll Never Use

Cars insurance companies offer all kinds of extra insurance coverage. Some of these additional endorsements just don’t apply to your situation. Picking every box may increase your premium without providing you real life benefits.

Look at your optional coverages and ask yourself if you need it. Consider your commute, your car’s age, and your budget before saying yes to add-ons.

Reevaluate Your Policy Each Year

Life changes. You may move, change jobs, buy a new vehicle, or pay off your loan. Any number of life changes can alter your insurance needs. Take time each year to review your policy and eliminate coverage that you no longer need.

Just because you once needed an insurance coverage doesn’t mean you still need it. Keep your policy streamlined and only filled with protections that you need.

Compare Prices Before You Renew

Insurance companies all weigh risk differently. That means you could very well find a lower price for the same coverage from a different company. Before you renew your policy each year, shop around.

       Get quotes regularly to know what your current insurance would cost you if you started new today.

       When you get quotes, ensure you are comparing the same deductibles and level of coverage.

       Ask about discounts.

       Ask if your policy can be customized.

Price shopping doesn’t have to be difficult. Keep these tips in mind and find the best price for the coverage you want.

Don’t Just Look at Price…

Your cheapest insurance option may not be the best option. Yes, you want to save money on your auto insurance, but not if you are sacrificing protection you may need. Don’t get distracted by small savings if it means going without important coverage.

Look for insurance that provides you the best value. Feel confident that you aren’t paying for unnecessary coverage, but you also have enough protection if you’re in an accident.

Simplify Your Car Insurance

Minimalist car insurance isn’t about having the bare minimum. It’s about paying for insurance that you need and skipping the stuff you don’t. Review your policy, make smart decisions about your coverage, and compare prices each year.

You can have control over your car insurance prices and still be well protected if the worst happens.

 

Comments